What do you think of Elon Musk? Have your say | No thanks
I'd like to buy a MINI or Audi A3 for a 14-mile commute - will a diesel be reliable for such short journeys?
Now that a nice lady has written off my Mercedes-Benz SLK I am looking to replace it with a diesel convertible. Due to the weather I haven't been able to test-drive yet, but I like the MINI and Audi A3. I commute 14 miles daily each way with local roads and one junction of M25. Would I be better with a petrol car due to the particulate filters? I like the idea of great economy.
Asked on 15 December 2010 by MK, Barnet
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3580e/3580e4406c2fcd19f2fc51e5541b5ba3c95e0f48" alt=""
14 miles each way will get the engine hot enough to regenerate the diesel particulate filter and with a regenerative alternator should recharge the battery. But these are some of the potential costs of an EU5 diesel between years three and six: Replacement diesel particulate filter: £500 - £1,000. Replacement dual mass flywheel: £1,000 - £1,500. Replacement EGR valve: £500 - £1,000. Replacement turbo: £1,500 -£2,000. Replacement timing belt and tensioner (where fitted): £500. All that adds up to considerably more than any saving on fuel even over 100,000 miles. The saving of 50mpg v/s 40mpg over 100,000 miles is about £2,500; the saving of 60mpg v/s 40mpg over 100,000 miles is about £6,000.
I'd be looking at a MINI (chain cam), an Audi A3 1.8TSI cabrio (chain cam) or BMW 1-Series cabrio (all chain cam).
I'd be looking at a MINI (chain cam), an Audi A3 1.8TSI cabrio (chain cam) or BMW 1-Series cabrio (all chain cam).
Similar questions
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0cfac/0cfac5b338450421429e8159a9668bff01787caf" alt=""
We have recently retired and are planning to spend around £20,000 on a new or nearly new car. Being conscious of escalating fuel costs we were planning to buy a diesel engine, but are now confused by the...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0cfac/0cfac5b338450421429e8159a9668bff01787caf" alt=""
In last Saturday's paper, you advised someone who does 10,000 miles a year that 'You don't do enough miles for a diesel.' I'd appreciate your opinion as to what mileage would suggest the need for a diesel,...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0cfac/0cfac5b338450421429e8159a9668bff01787caf" alt=""
We would like to buy either a Ford Focus hatchback or estate or a 2008 Ford C-Max from British Car Auctions, where we have purchased several cars in the past. The car will serve as an all purpose workhorse...
Related models
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/55448/55448b2bc83bc0aec2640135f83b4f036a42dad0" alt=""
Good choice of engines. Some petrol engines now chain cam. Comfortable and well built interior. cheap to run 1.6 TDI. Feels very refined especially on the motorway.