What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Why can't utility companies perform better road repairs after carrying out their work?

The poor quality of road surfaces in this country is frequently discussed in your column. Many factors are blamed, but in my experience the surfaces of roads in towns are in a dreadful state almost entirely because the have been dug up and poorly repaired by utility companies. I have been driving the same route to work across Swansea for almost 20 years, and time and again I have seen recently resurfaced roads dug up and left looking in a mess. As well as providing an uneven surface for driving, it makes the whole area look scruffy. The utility companies responsible are all large profitable corporations, surely they should contribute to the cost of resurfacing the whole road properly and not just filling in the trench they have just made? Do you know what happens in other countries?

Asked on 8 November 2010 by DP, Swansea

Answered by Honest John
A distinction has to be made between essential repairs and non-essential repairs. The utility companies cannot leave a gas leak, a broken water main or a collapsed sewer until the road needs resurfacing. And they don't have infinite resources. If they were compelled to completely resurface the roads every time they dug them up then that would be reflected in your utility bills. If all under-road utility upgrades were consolidated so they took place at the same time that would lead to complete road closures for years at a time. So there is no answer.
Tags: roadworks
Similar questions
When I started driving in 1968 even major roadworks were only slightly disruptive of traffic flow and usually managed by a man holding a stop/go board. Now, even minor works on little-used country roads...
I noticed that someone else had written to you about damage to their car from a newly-tarred road surface. I asked your advise in August 2012 and over one year later I am pleased to report that your recommendation...
My car, a Citroen C4 1.6 HDI, broke down with a very loud cracking noise from under the bonnet. The franchised dealer found the alternator drive belt was breaking up due to road grit ingress and the noise...