What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Why is this accident management company asking for my credit card details after an accident?

Yesterday I was involved in a very minor bump and I rang my insurers (Saga). They took all details and then suddenly handed me over to someone from "Claimfast". He said that he could arrange the repair of my car and also the replacement loan car during the repair. He then asked for either my credit card or debit card details. I remember reading in your Saturday features about excessive car hire charges and immediately told him that I will contact him at a later time. I am concerned that he said my car could be picked up this morning, and that a hire care would be brought out to me. I have visions of my car sitting for weeks on end before any attempt to repair it and that I would be landed with a massive bill should the insurance company not cover the cost. Am I right to be worried?

My second concern is that my car, a Mitsubishi Galant Estate V6 I have owned from new for nine years and has only 68,000 miles on the clock, has sustained damage to front and rear wings, nearside rear passenger door and scuffs to front passenger door. The damage is not extensive but I fear that because the car is not valued at very much, the insurance company may write it off, owing to the cost of repairs. How do I stop this and what course of action should I take?

Asked on 10 October 2010 by MS, Whitmore

Answered by Honest John
Don't give your credit or debit card details because what can happen is they put you in an expensive hire car, for which you are ultimately liable (that's why they want your credit card) and then delay the repair, extending the period of the hire. If your or the other party’s insurer refuses to pay the outrageous hire car rate, you are left liable and if you've given them your credit card details they simply nick it from your card account. Nice, eh?

A sensible insurer will allow you to get reasonable local quotes for repair of your car because that excludes credit hire operations posing as ‘accident management specialists’ from performing this sort of rip-off. Despite the fact that credit hire is one of the main reasons for huge increases in insurance premiums, there seems to be little enthusiasm within government to outlaw it. Maybe too many fingers in the pie.
Similar questions
I had a no fault accident and my insurance passed me onto an management company, who provided a replacement hire vehicle so I could keep working. Now third party are refusing to discharge the payment....
Your excellent column in Saturday's Telegraph exposes some serious issues, exemplified by MM of Hawick (13-08-11). Can you recommend a best procedure for dealing with an incident which requires car recovery...
I was interested to read your letter headed ‘Decline and Fall’ in the DT dated Saturday 13 August. I had an almost identical situation arise as MM of Hawick which involved the same insurance company. Last...