What do you think of Elon Musk? Have your say | No thanks

What should we buy to replace our Ford Fiesta?

We wish to change my wife's car - a 2012 Ford Fiesta Zetec. Our minimum requirements are a small car (about same size as current Fiesta), five doors, automatic, petrol, sat nav and a minimum 1.3-litre.

Reliability is very important and we're looking at new or recent second hand (no more than 2 years old)

Have you any recommendations? MINI, Polo, Corsa, Clio, i20, 208, Ibiza?

Asked on 26 February 2025 by Ian Williams

Answered by Matt Robinson
You can't really go wrong with any of the options you've mentioned, perhaps aside from the MINI, which is still a little lacking in practicality even in the five-door version. Our pick in this part of the market would be the Skoda Fabia (related to the Polo and Ibiza), although most you'll come across will use a 1.0-litre engine, which is common for the segment. It suits the car just fine, but if you're set on a larger engine, some higher-spec versions come with a 1.5-litre inline-four. Each is available with an automatic gearbox. You'll also need to double-check the spec of any you're looking at, as not all trim grades have navigation - some will require you to connect your phone via Android Auto/Apple CarPlay and use your device's mapping software (e.g. Google Maps).
Similar questions
Which small cars give the best ride over speed humps?
What would be best automatic small car to buy?
My wife wants to replace her 2012 Peugeot 208. We have looked at similar sized Kia and Hyundai vehicles but nothing is really grabbing our attention. We have seen a Suzuki Swift automatic with only 660...
Related models
Very refined and quiet for a small car. Impressive ride quality. Does everything very well.