What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Can you recommend a replacement for a BMW 528i Touring?

I need your advice on replacing my much loved (from new) and well-cared for BMW E39 of 1999 vintage because come next summer, if the Mayor of London has his way, it will be too costly to run with the expanded ULEZ.

A used BMW 3 Series Touring is top of my wish list, typically 2014-19 vintage, max spend up to £30,000 with a "reasonably low mileage" and a sunroof and a six cylinder engine, preferably petrol, but not totally adverse to a decent (BMW) oil burner. Or am I too optimistic hoping to fit all that in, considering my max spend?

Any other suggestions of similar motors that give a similar relaxed comfort and sense of well being like my current steed would be very welcome too. Preferably estate versions but could also look at a hatchback or a roomy convertible. I definitely prefer rear wheel drive.

Asked on 13 October 2022 by Mons Elmberg

Answered by Lawrence Allan
A BMW 340i Touring of around 2017 vintage with modest mileage is well within your grasp - sadly that's the only petrol 3 Series of this vintage with a six-cylinder engine. However as an all-rounder with better long-distance efficiency we'd push you towards the 330d or 335d models, which have smooth six-cylinder diesel engines with plenty of performance. Also check out the 4 Series with the same engines if a convertible is your bag - there aren't any comfort-focused six-cylinder hatchbacks, only the BMW M140i which is performance-focused. For comfort and refinement we'd also recommend trying out the Mercedes E-Class, which can be had within budget with either the E400/E450 petrol engine or the more commonly found E350d/E400d diesels. You might be looking at the previous generation version rather than the latest model for a budget of £30k - you'll need £35k for a low mileage latest model. However both versions can also be had in four-seat coupe or convertible forms.
Similar questions
My 2014 2.0-litre diesel auto BMW 5 Series falls foul of the clean air zone (CAZ) requirements. It's been my third 5 Series, used for my work as a surveyor. The rear seats fold to accommodate my ladders...
I have a 1999 Peugeot 406 diesel estate. It has 160k miles on the clock and I bought it for £2000 12 years ago. The expansion of the London ULEZ means that I have to change it, I really don't want to,...
I'm going to be taking my driving test soon so am looking to buy a reliable automatic. My budget is £20,000. I think I need something the size of a saloon as I will be doing around 18,000 miles per year...
Related models
Some great engines. Good ride and handling. Classy looks. Performed well in JD Power Customer Satisfaction surveys.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer