What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Is the Renault Zoe a safe car?

Two weeks ago I ordered a Renault Zoe but today read it got zero stars in the Euro NCAP safety tests. After speaking to Renault UK they say the airbags and the braking system modification/omission is due to the lack of computer chips. I am very reluctant to buy a car that doesn’t have five-star safely in a crash and feel I should cancel this order. What do you think? Is there another small electric car with a high safety spec?

Asked on 10 December 2021 by

Answered by Andrew Brady
There's an element of truth to what Renault's saying. The Zoe scored badly under the Safety Assist category – with Euro NCAP criticising its lack of features like automatic emergency braking and lane assist. Some of these will be introduced next year –which suggests it could be the chip shortage that is preventing them from being included now. Not having these features doesn't mean the Renault Zoe is fundamentally an unsafe car (structurally, it's no worse than the old model which scored five stars in less stringent Euro NCAP tests in 2013). If you want to consider an alternative, we'd recommend a Peugeot e-208 or Fiat 500 Electric. Both have been awarded four stars by NCAP but bear in mind that their standard specifications may have changed too.
Similar questions
Please advise if a used Citroen C4 Cactus is a good buy, given its 4-star Euro NCAP rating. I think this is due to the absence of autonomous emergency braking (AEB) when tested in 2014. Should this deter...
I am told that the Dacia Duster was tested by Euro NCAP in 2017 and received a three-star rating, with a 71% score for adult occupant protection, 66% for child occupant protection, 56% for pedestrian protection...
Have any of the pure electric cars been crash tested yet? If so, what were the results?
Related models
Fun and easy-going driving experience, decent ride quality, cabin, range and performance all improved in 2019