What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Why are diesel cars only recommended for high mileage drivers?

Why do car reviewers always recommend a petrol car for city drivers and a diesel car for those who do high mileage/motorway driving? If one gets more mileage from a diesel, isn't that vehicle a better fit for both city and motorway driving? What is the advantage of having petrol, apart from it being slightly cheaper? Please enlighten me!

Asked on 9 July 2021 by Ash

Answered by Dan Powell
I would question the nature of the mileage. For example, if you cover 10,000 miles in a diesel car but most of those journeys are short runs from cold, you will be inviting a range of mechanical problems because the engine will never reach its optimum operating temperature. We receive thousands of complaints from drivers who buy diesels for low-mileage use and most face huge repair bills for problems with the DPF (which traps harmful pollutants and burns them off) and other mechanical areas. Modern petrol cars do have PPFs (petrol particulate filters) which operate in a similar fashion to DPFs, but they seem less susceptible to blockages when use for regular trips of less than 15 miles.
Similar questions
Should I buy a diesel SUV? I drive about 7,000 - 8,000 miles a year, much of it short journeys in town.
With low annual milage, should I buy a diesel car?
I'm buying a Mercedes-Benz E-Class Convertible. Do I buy petrol or diesel? Which model do you recommend?