What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Air miles?

Do you come across many issues with the National Mileage Register? I have just put a deposit down on a used Porsche Boxster with a local dealer. It is a July 2006 with 26,900 miles for sale at £19,995. It is currently owned by a finance house under a contract hire plan, for which the selling dealer was the original broker. Even though it is with a dealer I thought I would do an HPI check for peace of mind. But this has flagged up a 'discrepancy' with the mileage.
The NMR shows the following entries only: 23/03/09: 26,000; 15/05/09 35,000; 08/06/09: 36,000. On calling HPI, I was told that all of these entries were provided by 'members of the public' and they can provide no further information. The conclusion is either the database is wrong, or the car has been clocked. The only evidence the dealer can provide is the service book that shows just one service (20,000 / 2 year intervals) at a main Porsche dealer on 04/06/08 at 19,400 miles. As a check, I called Porsche, who verified this service and also saw the car on 22/08/08 at 20,700 miles. Averaging this usage out would be consistent with the 26,900 now shown. I'm concluding that the database is wrong. I find it hard to believe that someone would clock a car from 36,000 to 26,900. In addition the high mileage shown on the database between March 09 to May 09 looks wrong (unless the car suddenly did 9,000 miles in 7 weeks having done 26,000 in the previous 3 years). HPI acknowledged this and are looking into it, but I wondered if you have come across this before and whether you think I should be worried?
As the dealer provided the car from new and 'knows' the car, he will
warrant the mileage in writing.

Asked on 29 August 2009 by

Answered by Honest John
If a driver runs the car 'unhooked' or clocks it in between services then the system cannot pick this up unless something untoward happens, like a puncture, or an MoT, and the tyre dealer or MoT tester logs the mileage into the register. This might have happened unbeknown to the driver and since Porsche prices are very mileage sensitive (and the car may have been on a mileage sensitive lease) he might have subsequently clocked it. (You can now check mileages registered at MoTs.)
Dear Honest John,

Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:
    Select a few terms below
Similar questions
We bought a car with our wedding money about seven weeks ago from a dealer. We found the dealer to be very nice and we test drove the car, and although the previous MOT wasn't available we saw the service...
In 2007 I purchased through eBay a Ford Galaxy 1.9TDI with 98,000 miles on the clock for £4500.00. Having spent about £1500 in two years on various mechanical parts I decided to get rid of it using a well-known...
A local used car dealer has a 2009 59 Volvo for sale in lovely condition. He has told me that it was stolen from his pitch 8 months ago at 20,000m but turned up in Kent at the end of December (someone...
Related models
Enjoyable and easy to drive, wonderful engine sound, great performance, surprisingly practical for a two-seat sports car, good automatic PDK gearbox.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer