What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Win diesel

You state that in lower temperatures diesels use more fuel. What is the thermodynamic basis for this statement? I find it difficult to figure out why this should be. I have thought of the following: 1) low temperatures means the engine takes longer to reach operating temperature (exacerbated by the greater mass of a diesel engine), but this should only be a problem for very short journeys, as with petrol engines. 2) lower induction air temperature (even after passing through a turbo) could lead to a lower adiabatic compression temperature on the compression stroke, would that really make a significant difference, especially in a 'hot' engine? 3) as with all injection systems, the pump delivers a volume, but the energy depends upon the mass delivered. At lower temperatures a given volume has a greater mass, but that should be self-compensating by adjustment of the foot on the accelerator. The mass delivered can be affected by the specific gravity of the fuel, which can vary a little from source to source and hence affect the consumption, but to this extent?

Asked on 7 March 2009 by

Answered by Honest John
They are more thermodynamically efficient. They convert less energy to heat and more to power. Consequently they take longer to reach full running temperature. Actually about 10 miles in temperatures around zero v/s 2 - 3 miles in summer. My Focus ECOnetic is currently doing 49 - 50 v/s 57 - 60 in higher ambient temperatures. But obviously, after 10 miles, there would be no difference, so the
greatest difference is felt in vehicles used for comparatively short
journeys, not those doing 300 miles a day, unless they are running on low cetane winter diesel. Shell says its winter diesel is not lower cetane, but others might be.
Similar questions
I have just bought a 2004 manual BMW 320 diesel ES Tourer. I switched on the computer at the start of a run largely in 6th gear of 130 motorway miles. At the end I had done no better than 45mpg according...
My five year old Mercedes-Benz E550 has done 17,000 miles and has had the brake pads replaced and now the rotors. Apparently the reason for the rotor failure was that I drove too little. My wife had a...
I have Yokohama W Drive drive fitted to my 4wd diesel auto Nissan Qashqai; when driving in snow should you have the ABS/EBD turned on or off - I am receiving conflicting advice? Also is it better in...