What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Partic bristle

Time after time I read you comments about problems with DPFs and todays' copy of the Telegraph was no exception. I personally had my first problem after approximately one year with my new Nissan X-Trail and the supplier duly cured the problem (because I could not) under warranty, although I suspect it cost me quite a few gallons of diesel. I was told at the time that new software had been installed which changes the operating conditions of the engine/DPF and it should not happen again. So far, 6 months later, it has not. My car does what I imagine thousands of others do: around 12,000 miles a year made up of journeys to say Yorkshire or Devon, perhaps 2/3 trips to France with much Autoroute travel and round trips of say 3,000 miles. In between there will be plenty of short journey stuff. Surely "normal" usage. Now I am quite sure that Nissan does not say in its sales brochures that "this car is not suitable for small journeys". Therefore it seems to me that the problem is being swept under the carpet and that cars fitted with DPFs should be recalled and fitted with equipment fit for purpose, or the DPF should be removed, or, at the very least, the manufacturer should give a guarantee for the lifetime of the car to regenerate the DPF in the case of a problem.

Asked on 4 September 2010 by MR, St Albans

Answered by Honest John
The campaign already exists and has been appearing in my column for about 3 years. It simply tells people that if they do not do at least 15,000 miles a year and if they contemplate multiple short runs from cold they should not buy a car with a diesel particulate filter. The device collects smut particles on start up to prevent them emitting into the atmosphere. It then burns them off at very high temperature later in the car's journey. If there is no "later" it does not burn them off and the DPF gets clogged, causing all sorts of problems, including destroyed engines.
Similar questions
I understand you have recently written on the subject of DPFs. My particular experience of the current X-Trail diesel (and my ongoing quarrel with Nissan) is that the first time the warning light came...
In April 2009 I bought a one-year-old Nissan X-trail. At the end of July, having covered 2000 miles in France in just over a week the particulate light again came on together with the Malfunction light....
The DPF on my 2010 Ford Mondeo TDCi burnt out, glowed red, smoked and then the exhaust dropped after 109,000 miles. No warning lights came up on dash. Can I just replace the DPF or do I need to sort out...
Related models
Excellent drive on tarmac and very competent off road, large boot, plenty of standard equipment.