Legal A’d

What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Legal A’d

I have a seven-year-old semi-auto Mercedes A-Class petrol 190 that has suited me, but now I should replace it with something similar. I liked its performance and its high seating, which makes getting in and out easier for my stiff legs. I fancy changing to a diesel engine but the new A Class all have lower performance. Do you have any ideas on a car of similar spec to the old A190 with 0-60 in around 8 seconds.

Asked on 27 February 2010 by N.C., via e-mail

Answered by Honest John

The W169 A Class models are much better quality than the original A Class, even if there isn't a quick one. Best to take a test drive. One of the nicest engines in an MPV type vehicle is the chain-cam Nissan water-cooled turbo 1.4TCe 130 in the new Scenic. You can also get the VAG 1.4TSI 122 (probably more like 130 really) in the Golf +. Or wait for the superb Ford S-Max to get its efficient new 205PS (200bhp) SCTI engine and Powershift twin clutch transmission. Quality of that is easily as high as of any Mercedes.

Tags: buying mpvs new cars

Dear Honest John,

Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:

Similar questions

C-max v S-max

We are looking for a Ford seven-seater. Should we go for the C-Max or S-Max? And which model?

Sweetest seven

I need a good-sized 5-seater with occasional seats for 7 to replace my VW Touran. We have test driven both the Ford S-Max and Hyundai Santa Fe but cannot decide. Which is better in terms of refinement...

Family plan

With sons of 7 and 4 and twins arriving in 6 weeks we need to replace our trusty old SAAB 900, within a budget of £15k. We live in London but most mileage (to about 10k pa) will be on Motorways in the...

Related models